Batch vs. Continuous
The interest in continuous mixing and kneading is growing rapidly as food manufacturers seek new ways to increase throughput and product quality while keeping operational costs down. As a result, more and more food producers are asking themselves whether to go for batch or continuous mixing. Below careful comparison will help determine which mixing technology suits which production process best.
BATCH MIXING means all ingredients are (manually) loaded into a mixer for duration until they are homogeneously distributed or mixed. After that, they are discharged and a new batch is being produced. Batch processing has been the chosen technology of the bakery industry for many years. Even though a batch system is still the most widely used system, it might not be the best choice for your particular application.
CONTINUOUS MIXING works based on the first in first out principle, and is the process of continuously weighing ingredients directly into the mixing chamber and discharging a continuous stream of mixed product at the outlet of the continuous mixer. Generally larger operations will benefit from continuous mixing due to shorter mixing times and higher output capacities. There is little to no labor involved because of the automation controls in place.
THE RISE OF CONTINUOUS..
When the first Industrial bakeries came into being, batch mixers could satisfy the bakers needs and wants. However, as food demand grew so did the size of the food production factories and conclusively production output. As a result, newer technologies can produce larger quantities of dough (up to 12.000 kg/hr) in one and the same system. These continuous mixing solutions are fully automated and require almost no manpower, have an accurate recipe control and a consistent product quality. You must be thinking..why didn’t we hear of this technology sooner?
The answer is that until around 20 years ago, the ingredient handling and weighing technologies were not advanced enough to feed the mixer at rates high enough to meet the demand of the continuous mixing process. The past two decades, this technology has advanced immensely enabling an extremely accurate dosing of seperate ingredients into the continuous mixing system. Consequently, more and more bakeries question whether to choose batch or a continuous dough mixing system.
Batch mixing is seen as the most established and traditional way of blending raw materials – simply because these mixers were available when continuous did not exist yet. The development of improved mixing, controlling and metering resulted in continuous mixing systems that are reliable, easy-to-use and able to provide a consistent product quality.
There are still quite some misconceptions in regards to how pricing on a continuous mixer compares to the pricing on a batch mixer. The rootcause of this misunderstanding lies in the fact that the cost of a continuous mixing system is often compared to the cost of a batch mixer. What we mean with that is that a continuous mixer supplier generally offers a complete system which includes weighing of the ingredients and the actual mixing of the product. This is done because on a continuous mixer, ingredients cannot be dosed manually. This has to be done automatically and be accurate every split second. Often the price of such system is compared to the price of solely a batch mixer (without the dosing). In that case, evidently the continuous mixing system will have a higher initial investment compared to the batch mixer.
However, dosing directly at the mixer (in case of a continuous mixing proces) results in greater automation and accuracy. Therefore, it is concluded that on the short term this might results in an higher initial investment but on the long term, due to improved consistency and a higher automation grade, in a lower cost of ownership.
While continuous mixing of dough is readily credited with operational and cost advantages, many food producers also select continuous mixing based on the promise of increased product consistency and quality.
Creating dough in discrete batches will always introduce slight variations from batch to batch. While these seem manageable they will always lead to inconsistency over time. Trying to manage quality while chasing these variables will add to the already higher and ongoing labor cost of batch mixing. On top of the inherent variation introduced by the mixing process itself, batch mixing implies that the batch of dough will spend some amount of time waiting to be processed after being mixed.
Dough is a living entity where chemical and physical changes take place from the time water is added to the dry ingredient until the product is finished baking. The dough will change over that period of time due to aging, environmental conditions and the interactions of the seperate ingredients.
These batch-to-batch dough variations result in varying piece weights which create inconsistencies during packaging. On a continuous mixing process there is a continuous stream of dough meaning every piece of dough has had the same fermentation process and age. This constant consistency is one of the largest benefits to continuous dough mixing and strongly contributes to the growing popularity.
BULK DELIVERY OF RAW MATERIALS
Generally, the same delivery systems can be used for both batch as well as continuous food processing (possibly pneumatic transfer from silo to receiver).
The pricing difference between a batch or continuous system depends on whether you feed your batch mixer manually or in an automated way. In case of batch mixing, the weighing of the ingredients can be done manually; saving significant costs on the short term. In case of continuous mixing, the dosing of raw materials needs to be done automatically at the mixer and requires greater automation and accuracy. As a result, the product quality is independent of the skills of the operators. Even though, the initial investment of the automated ingredient weighing might be higher on a continuous mixing system; on the long term the improved weighing technology will represent significant cost savings. Think of less waste due to more accurate weighing during packaging and minimzed labor costs.
Batches of dough typically come in an unpractical form, meaning that additional equipment is required to resize the batches. This additional process step creates unnecessary shear and exposure of the dough. A continuous mixer creates continuous streams of dough that can be cut in-line. Generally on a continuous mixing process, there is no need for additional equipment to resize the batches.
Batch mixing is seen as the most established and traditional way of blending raw materials – simply because these mixers were available when continuous did not exist yet. The development of improved mixing, controlling and weighing resulted in continuous mixing system that is reliable, easy-to-use and able to provide a consistent product quality. Nevertheless, Sobatech understands that organizing your production process in a new innovative way can be exciting. Therefore, Sobatech has its own testing facility allowing you to overcome possible perceived risks of changing to a new innovative type of mixing.
MORE INFORMATION? CONTACT US!
Product temperature calculator
Curious about the optimum temperature for your production line? Make free use of our thermal calculator. Enter your details below and you can get started within 1 minute.